The Serendipitous Gifts of Studying the Alexander Technique

The occurrence and development of events by chance in a happy or beneficial way.

                  –Serendipity  (as defined by the Oxford Dictionary of the English Language)

It was my frightening and frustrating struggle as a saxophonist with focal dystonia (a neurologically based movement disorder that impairs coordination) that brought me to the Alexander Technique.

As I began to do more research on my condition, it became evident to me that, even though my focal dystonia symptoms were experienced through my muscles, they only ever surfaced whenever I began to prepare to play saxophone (more precisely, the moment I began to think  about playing).

In the simplest sense, it was my reaction to the thought of playing saxophone  that was triggering my focal dystonia symptoms.

After doing a good amount of research about the Alexander Technique as it applied to musical performance (and considerable amount of reading about the neuroscience of learning and unlearning), one key truth stood out to me that prompted me to seek out a certified Alexander teacher: Thought precedes and conditions reaction.

“So”, I said to myself, “if I can learn to think and react in a different, more constructive way when I play saxophone, I’ll have the best chance at improving my focal dystonia symptoms.”

I’m happy to say that this has proven to be true.

Resoundingly so.

And in the process of applying the Alexander Technique in addressing my focal dystonia symptoms, I became absolutely intrigued by the efficacy and possibilities of the work.

So much so that I decided to commit to the 3-year training program to become certified to teach this work.

The Alexander Technique continues to be my most effective tool in helping both my clients (mostly professional and serious student musicians) and myself as a musician.

If you’re not familiar with the Alexander Technique, it’s a practical set of principles you use to become aware of the (often) unconscious habits of misdirected effort (things that take you out of your optimal coordination) that you bring into your activities (like playing music!). By studying and applying the Technique, you learn to prevent or lessen these unwanted habits by changing your thinking, bringing  yourself back to your natural, optimal coordination.

It’s about learning to respond  to things in a more conscious and constructive way, instead of reacting  habitually (and sometimes harmfully).

Lots of  musicians who regularly take Alexander lessons rave about how the Technique makes playing feel easier, more natural, and with far less tension/effort than they’ve ever experienced before.

It’s helpful for decreasing/eliminating chronic back, neck, shoulder, jaw and wrist pain, as well as improving breathing, and balance (obviously helpful for any instrumentalist or singer!)

And even though I myself  wasn’t motivated to seek out and Alexander teacher because of the maladies mentioned above, I did indeed suffer from most of them (especially back and shoulder pain!)

I was usually in some sort of state of discomfort  when playing my instrument, just chalking it all up to “working hard”. I accepted pain as part and parcel of what a serious musician struggles with.

No, my motivation was simply about restoring (or at least improving) my coordination  when playing saxophone. Period.

But as I began to take lessons, it wasn’t long at all that my back began to feel better (not just when playing, but all the time!), my shoulders began to widen and become freer, my jaw became flexible and responsive, and my breathing became more full, easy and supportive of my saxophone sound.

All great things, for sure!

I began to describe these other changes I was experiencing to my friends and colleagues as “serendipitous gifts”, meaning I was blessed in finding such positive things I wasn’t even looking for.

(And as you might have wondered/guessed by now, my focal dystonia symptoms were inextricably connected to the misdirected muscular effort that was causing these pains I’d been experiencing for so many years.)

Yet the most cherished, most profoundly life-changing serendipitous gift I found in studying the Alexander Technique was more simple, more basic, more essential to my personal well-being and growth as a musician:

I learned to treat myself with kindness.

This kindness includes how I treat myself when practicing and performing:

How I changed my previously harsh and rather loud “self-talk voice” to one of soft inquiry and assurance;

How I allow myself to be wrong in order to discover new ideas and techniques;

How I give myself permission to pause when practicing in order to redirect my efforts;

How I allow myself to rest optimally;

How I listen to myself (and the other musicians) with a more detailed presence;

How I allow myself to peacefully walk away from an exercise (or even a practice session) if it isn’t going just right and I can’t seem to put myself back on track;

How I accept and trust my efforts, sound and intentions when performing.

And so much more…

One of the biggest changes in how I treat myself is that, even when I’m doing something “wrong” when practicing or performing, that I don’t interpret that to mean that there is something wrong with me.

That’s huge for me, as it places me squarely in a place of gratitude, with an almost child-like curiosity when I practice. And feeling grateful, is perhaps, the most beautiful of all states of being.

As I’ve mentioned in some of my other blog posts, practice for me is now a form of meditation. It’s nourishing and ever so pleasurable.

And as a bonus, my saxophone practice has become more dynamic, more efficient, more directly helpful to me than it ever was.

All this because of the gift of kindness I give myself.

You see, when applying the Alexander Technique to any activity, you are learning to redirect your thinking in the most helpful way you can.

To do this, you must ask  things of yourself, rather than demand  them. (You can’t bully yourself into reacting constructively!)

I “ask” for my optimal coordination. I do so with kindness and deference. With sincere respect and love.

That makes all the difference.

I feel compelled to talk about all of this in my first blog post of the year because of my experience over these past years teaching the Alexander Technique to musicians.

I’ve had the honor and pleasure to share this work with (quite literally) some world-class performers.

And one thing I continue to notice is how harsh many of these wonderful artists can be with themselves as they approach practice and performance.

Of course they seek excellence! Of course they are disciplined! Of course they have high standards! Of course they’re willing to sacrifice!

But what they learn when studying with me is that it is often their fierce self-talk that is taking them out of their optimal coordination, taking them away from getting precisely what they want.

As their coordination improves, it does so by going hand in hand with their self-directed kindness. They ask instead of demand and marvel at the results. It’s about as “win-win” as you can get.  A beautiful thing.

So I’ll continue to enjoy and cultivate my serendipitous gifts, and graciously share them with my students, living a musical life of gratitude, exploration, growth and satisfaction.

7 thoughts on “The Serendipitous Gifts of Studying the Alexander Technique

  1. Robin Challis

    Hey Bill, that’s very inspiring and provides me with a thread I would like to pull on .. If you don’t mind: I’m 61 years old, male, started playing sax quite late in life – about 20 years ago .. so an enthusiastic amateur. When I started it was very important to me, psychologically, spiritually, and I went at it hell for leather. Zing! Got RSI in my arm and had to stop playing for about a year and a half. But it did start me on the road to learning more about my body – got into Feldenkreis mainly, and general fitness and eventually got back in the saddle. Now, recently, after a long period of doing the same old, same old, in order to up my game I started a fantastic online course (Bebop Bootcamp), which has had all sorts of benefits. But once again – zing! – the body didn’t like it – shoulders, back, arm all screaming. So I put the horn down and have been really exploring my posture. And I’m loving it. Feel like a king. And just yesterday picked up my horn again with my new awareness. However, I know that this is just the beginning of the road – so, any guidance from an Alexander Technique perspective would be very much appreciated. I live in Ireland, by the way .. play the tenor (a Keilwerth) nowadays, mainly .. All best, Robin

    Reply
    1. BillBill Post author

      Hi Robin, nice to hear from you! I would recommend that you find a good Alexander Technique teacher, and commit to taking at least 10 lessons. That’s a good way to understand how the Technique works and how to apply it. If you can find a certified teacher that specializes in working with musicians, all the better. But even if you can’t, a well-trained AT teacher can really help. Feldenkrais work is wonderful, and I’ve studied it myself, but for me (and many students who’ve come to me for help), nothing beats the immediate practicality of the Alexander Technique. You see, it’s not just about “posture”, but about how reactions manifest themselves into movement (for better or worse), and how you can learn to react more in cooperation with your human design (and your desires as a musician). I’m going on 62 years, practice the saxophone 2 to 4 hours a day and have no pain whatsoever. (I can’t say that same thing about myself 20 years ago before discovering the Technique, when I was in pain most of the time.)

      Also, if you haven’t read it, I highly recommend you read this article I wrote some time ago. Still rings true! https://billplakemusic.org/2011/07/20/three-things-to-address-to-practice-in-a-healthy-way/
      And you also might want to check the “self care for musicians” category in my blog posts. Lots of useful ideas there. Best wishes to you! Thanks for your thoughts!

      Reply
      1. Robin Challis

        Great, Bill .. thanks for your many suggestions. I will follow them up – have already tracked down an AT teacher who is also a musician, in Dublin. And I’ll read your other suggestions. Tnks mill!

        Reply
  2. Magdalena Portmann

    What a great post! My story is different, but the side effects of taking lessons are very much the same!

    Reply
      1. Magdalena Portmann

        I shared your article with some colleagues – and one of the replies was that this is the “…most tenderly thought-full + informative piece about AlexTech that I’ve ever read.” And I agree entirely. I want to share this with my U3A class. You write with passion and humility.

        Reply
        1. BillBill Post author

          Thank you for those very kind words, Magdalena, and thank you for sharing my post. It does my heart good to know that people are finding my thoughts and experiences helpful.

          Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.